At JayArr Coffee, we are always trying new coffees- from the offerings of the major companies like Peet’s/Starbucks to microroasters from around the world. This page is intended to serve as a summary of our reviews. We’ll try our best to keep it up-to-date – happy brewing!
-JayArr
For your information, if you click on a link to a product on Jayarrcoffee.com and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.
| Coffee Name | JayArr Score | Full Review At | Available At |
| Peet’s Reserve Jamaica Blue Mountain | 4.9 | Peet’s Gift Set | Seasonally at: Peet’s Reserve Page |
| Peach Coffee Sumatra Lintong | 4.8 | Sumatran Coffee | Peach Roasters |
| Kicking Horse Dark Roast | 4.7 | Organic Coffee | Amazon |
| Peet’s Arabian Mocha Sanani | 4.7 | 3 Coffee Comparison | Peet’s |
| Volcanica Coffee Sumatra Mandheling | 4.6 | Sumatran Coffee | Volcanica |
| Peet’s Reserve Red Mocha Haraaz | 4.6 | Peet’s Gift Set | Seasonally at: Peet’s Reserve Page |
| Bizzy Cold Brew Roast | 4.5 | Organic Coffee | Amazon |
| Peet’s Ethiopian Super Natural | 4.5 | Ethiopian Coffee | Seasonally at: Peet’s |
| Peet’s Sumatra | 4.5 | Sumatran Coffee | Amazon |
| La Colombe Colombia – San Roque | 4.5 | Colombian Coffee | La Colombe |
| Peet’s Yosemite Dos Sierra | 4.5 | Single Origin Reviews | Peet’s |
| Counter Culture Forty Six | 4.5 | Wegman’s Reviews | Amazon |
| Real Good Coffee Co. Dark | 4.4 | Organic Coffee | Amazon |
| Coava Coffee Kilenso Ethiopia | 4.4 | Ethiopian Coffee | Coava |
| Two Volcanoes Guatemala | 4.4 | 3 Coffee Comparison | Amazon |
| Peet’s Guatemalan San Sebastian | 4.4 | Single Origin Reviews | Peet’s |
| La Colombe Corsica | 4.38 | Wegman’s Reviews | Amazon |
| Tiny Footprint Cold Press | 4.3 | Organic Coffee | Amazon |
| Stone Street Tanazania Peaberry | 4.3 | 3 Coffee Comparison | Amazon |
| La Colombe Yirgacheffe | 4.25 | Ethiopian Coffee | La Colombe |
| Peet’s Major Dickason’s Blend | 4.25 | Wegman’s Reviews | Amazon |
| Starbucks Sumatra | 4.2 | Sumatran Coffee | Amazon |
| Volcanica Organic Guatemalan | 4.1 | Organic Coffee | Volcanica |
| Jo Coffee Decaf | 4.1 | Organic Coffee | Amazon |
| Volcanica Ethiopian Yirgacheffe | 4.1 | Ethiopian Coffee | Volcanica |
| Starbucks PNG | 4 | Single Origin Reviews | Amazon |
| Coffee Bean Direct Dark Sumatra | 3.9 | Sumatran Coffee | Amazon |
| Birch Coffee Ethiopian Yirgacheffe | 3.75 | Ethiopian Coffee | Birch Coffee |
| Cafe Don Pablo Organic | 3.7 | Organic Coffee | Amazon |
| Koffee Kult Sumatra | 3.5 | Sumatran Coffee | Amazon |
| Stumptown Coffee – Narino Borderlands | 3.5 | Colombian Coffee | Seasonally Available at: Stumptown |
| Cafe Altura Organic Colombian | 3.5 | Colombian Coffee | Amazon |
| Pike’s Place | 3.5 | Wegman’s Reviews | Amazon |
| Coffee Bean Direct PNG | 3.3 | Organic Coffee | Amazon |
| Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC Sumatra | 3.25 | Sumatran Coffee | Amazon |
| Cooper’s Ethiopian Whole Bean | 3 | Ethiopian Coffee | Amazon |
| Jim’s Organic Colombian – Santa Marta | 3 | Colombian Coffee | Amazon |
| Eight O’Clock Colombian | 3 | Colombian Coffee | Amazon |
| Jim’s Organic Ethiopian Sidamo | 2.75 | Ethiopian Coffee | Jim’s Organic |
| Death Wish Coffee | 2.5 | Organic Coffee | Death Wish |
| Coffee Bean and Tea Leaf Colombian | 2.5 | Colombian Coffee | Amazon |
| Maxwell House Original | 2.25 | Wegman’s Reviews | Amazon |
| Folgers Classic Roast | 1.5 | Wegman’s Reviews | Amazon |
